1.How do you grade art without grading talent?
Why they ask
Parents push back on art grades, and principals need to know your grades are defensible when a family calls.
How to answer
- Grade against the lesson's objective, like using value to show form, not against how 'good' the drawing looks
- Share a simple rubric with students before they start
- Count process: sketchbook planning, revisions, use of class time
- Give an example of a student who drew stiffly but earned a strong grade by hitting every criterion

